“There’s a right way to do things, and a wrong way!” My Dad used to say. “And you always choose the wrong way!” All artists have a natural proclivity to doing things the other way, a different way, and “the wrong way”. Those who want to write a best-seller, sing a top 40 song, or sell a mainstream painting, study up on the trends of the market, and they have all their formulas for success spelled out for them in the various “self-help” guides that are available in the marketplace. Artists, true artists, are the freaks, the odd balls, and the weirdoes of our society.
If these artists didn’t have certain predilections in life, they probably would’ve been better athletes in high school, and more popular, and less inclined to eventually have the angst that drove them to do what they would ended up doing. They probably would’ve made better employees, better spouses, better parents, and better people. Their people probably would’ve enjoyed their company more if they fell in line with the practiced repetitions that led to better muscle memory in all these avenues of life. They probably would’ve been happier people and fit into society better, but they chose a different path in life.
“Everything great in the world comes from Neurotics. They alone have founded our religion and composed our masterpieces,” –Marcel Proust.
To say that an artist chooses his path in life is a bit of a misnomer, for most artists fell into expression as a form of therapy. They’ve usually had an incident, or a series of incidents, that they couldn’t quite get past in the accepted ways, but they made decisions on how to deal with them in their own way. Most artists didn’t “reach out” for others to help them deal with that which plagued them, or if they did they recognized the fact that most people don’t care about other people’s problems. Either that, or they didn’t receive any satisfaction from sympathetic responses. Most artists internalized their pain, until it exploded into some form of expression.
Expression meant free-form expression to them early on. It meant being outrageous, and offensive, and playing the game by their own rules. If they had good mentors though, they learned that much of this resulted in sloppy and undisciplined work. The whole reason they entered this field of expression was to expunge the toxins they had coursing through their veins, but their mentors told them there were rules and guidelines to doing this properly. Most artists angrily accepted that fact. They believed that artists should think outside the box, but they learned that true artists would eventually have to know what was in the box is if they ever hoped to violate it properly.
A friend of mine is not artistic, but he reads a lot of novels, and he knows their rules. He also gets bogged down in details. He circles offensive material, and he suggests that I delete, or edit, those portions. He doesn’t know art in this sense, and he doesn’t care. He knows the rules of society, and how those rules were applied by Hemingway and Faulkner, and he knows I’m offensive. This friend wouldn’t be able to write one word of fiction. He could get so boxed in by the rules that every word would be written, edited, and then deleted. He would write a novel that would be as entertaining as an instructional manual for a park bench, or the proper use of fly paper. He would’ve made a better editor, if he came to that crossroad.
The differences between an individual who knows the rules, but doesn’t know how to apply them in an artistic manner, are the differences between an artistic writer and an editor. Take a look at some of the names of the people who have written the articles on developing the perfect character, or the most dynamic conflict. You’ve probably never heard of them, for they know as little about writing an artistic novel as you do. Some people are excellent editors and teachers, but they know little to nothing about being an artist. The opposite is usually true of artists, and this is why freelance editors are making such a great living in the age of the rule breaking, freelance eBook writer. It is also why the advice of most artists, such as myself, is to just do it. Don’t talk about writing, don’t hold yourself up as a writer when you don’t write, and don’t complain about the arduous process involved. Just do it! Doing it, will help you figure out why you can do it or not. The other important note on this topic is that those who teach can’t teach you how to write your novel. They can give you general guidelines that you’ll need to know, but they can’t teach you the art of writing, and the art of letting your freak flag fly, in the vein that you’ll learn by just doing it. I’m not saying that their advice is without merit, but don’t let yourself get bogged down in the detail.